Let the Cuban People Build their Own Future
Free The Cuban People
By Nelson Caraballo
We agree on one fundamental point: the Cuban people are the ones who suffer.
The reality is that the communist dictatorship has never shown a genuine willingness to make meaningful economic changes or establish free and democratic elections. It is important to separate the consequences of the U.S. embargo from the internal decisions made by the Cuban government itself.
Trump has only been in power for one year. Cuba’s economic problems did not begin with Trump or with the most recent sanctions. Cuba has been dealing with structural problems for decades, largely because of an economic system in which the state controls practically everything: production, trade, prices, and much of the business sector.
Cubans living outside the island, especially in the United States, send billions of dollars to our families every year just to help them survive. The Cuban government itself benefits from that money through its currency-exchange and commercial mechanisms.
It is also important to clarify something that is repeated constantly: the U.S. embargo does not mean that Cuba cannot trade with the rest of the world.
Cuba has traded for decades with Canada, Spain, Mexico, China, Brazil, the European Union, and many other countries. It imports food, medicine, fuel, and consumer products from different parts of the world.
The United States also sells agricultural products and food to Cuba under exceptions established by U.S. law. These include chicken, pork, corn, soybeans, rice, dairy products, and other foods.
So there is a question that deserves a serious answer:
If the embargo were the only cause of Cuba’s problems, why didn’t Cuba become a prosperous economy during the decades when it had trade relations and economic support from so many countries?
And there is an even more important question:
Where did the billions of dollars and resources Cuba received for decades from the Soviet Union and the countries of COMECON go?
For approximately 30 years, Cuba received enormous economic benefits from the Soviet Union: subsidized oil, loans, favorable trade agreements, and economic assistance. Yet when the Soviet Union collapsed in 1991, the Cuban economy practically collapsed as well, leading to what became known as the Special Period.
That shows that the problem cannot simply be explained by saying, “The United States won’t let Cuba work.”
Marxist theory may sound good in books, but an economic system must ultimately be judged by its results.
And Cuba’s results are right in front of us.
It was not the United States that prohibited Cubans from having contact with family members who had emigrated.
It was not the United States that prohibited certain religious expressions for years and turned children’s education into an instrument of political indoctrination.
It was not the United States that censored artists, writers, musicians, and journalists for thinking differently.
It was not the United States that expropriated practically all private businesses and concentrated the economy in the hands of the state.
It was not the United States that restricted Cubans for decades from freely buying and selling their own homes and automobiles.
It was not the United States that prevented Cubans from freely developing private businesses and selling their own products.
It was not the United States that created a wage system in which highly educated professionals receive salaries in pesos while many essential products are sold in currencies or markets inaccessible to a large portion of the population.
It was not the United States that created laws against the illegal slaughter of cattle, with extremely severe penalties.
It was not the United States that imprisoned thousands of Cubans for political reasons or for protesting against the government.
It was not the United States that established a one-party system and eliminated genuine political competition.
It was not the United States that eliminated free elections and the separation of powers.
It was not the United States that decided that the state should control practically the entire economy.
It was not the United States that sent thousands of young Cubans to wars in Africa and other parts of the world for decades.
It was not the United States that made the decisions that led Cuba to accumulate enormous foreign debt and subsequently default on its obligations.
And it was not the United States that decided to maintain for decades an economic model that depends on assistance and financing from other countries to survive.
Those are decisions made by the Cuban government.
Saying this does not mean denying that the U.S. embargo has consequences. Of course it does. You can oppose the embargo while also recognizing that the Cuban government is responsible for its own policies.
But blaming everything on the so-called “blockade” ignores more than six decades of internal decisions.
Because if the embargo were the explanation for everything, how do we explain the fact that other countries that have traded freely with Cuba for decades have not turned Cuba into a prosperous economy?
How do we explain the failure of agriculture?
How do we explain the lack of domestic production?
How do we explain the blackouts?
How do we explain inflation?
How do we explain the mass emigration?
How do we explain the lack of political freedoms?
How do we explain that millions of Cubans have decided to leave their country in search of opportunities and a different life?
We do not judge a system by what it promised in a book. We judge it by what it produced in real life.
And after more than six decades, the result is right in front of us:
An impoverished people, a devastated economy, an aging population, and millions of Cubans living outside the island.
So when someone says that all of Cuba’s problems are the fault of the “blockade,” the question we should ask is very simple:
What responsibility does the Cuban government have for the decisions it has made over more than six decades?
It’s very simple:
Hold free elections. Release political prisoners. Allow Cubans to express themselves without fear. Allow distributors to enter the country and operate without the government controlling the products and how they are sold. And allow Cubans to freely own and operate their own businesses.
That’s it. Give the Cuban people freedom, and let them build their own future.
